Our website has detected that you are using Internet Explorer (IE) - a browser we no longer support. We recommend switching browsers to avoid issues with features on the site. View supported browsers here.
Baking Supplies

Gordon Choice

Unsalted Butter

Butter Prints, Unsalted, Grade AA, 1 Lb Block

$4.99
Block
Price: 4.99 Block

Gordon Choice

Salted Butter

Butter Prints, Salted, Grade AA, 1 Lb Block

$4.99
Block
Price: 4.99 Block

Hershey's

Semi Sweet Chocolate Chips

Chocolate Chips, Semi-Sweet, Baking, 12 Oz Package

$4.49
Package
Price: 4.49 Package

Hershey's

Milk Chocolate Chips

Chocolate Chips, Milk, Baking, 11.5 Oz Package

$4.49
Package
Price: 4.49 Package

Milk Chocolate M&M's Minis

Candy, Milk Chocolate, Mini, Holiday Baking, 10 Oz Bag

$6.49
Bag
Price: 6.49 Bag

Heath

Milk Chocolate Toffee Bits

Topping, Heath Milk Chocolate Toffee, Baking, Gluten Free, No Preservatives, 8 Oz Package

$4.49
Package
Price: 4.49 Package

Reese's

Peanut Butter Chips

Chocolate Chips, Peanut Butter, Baking, 10 Oz Package

$4.49
Package
Price: 4.49 Package

Andes

Peppermint Crunch Baking Chips

Stir-Ins, Peppermint Crunch Chip, 10 Oz Bag

$4.99
Bag
Price: 4.99 Bag

Gordon Choice

Mini Marshmallows

Marshmallows, Mini, 1 Lb Bag

$3.49
Bag
Price: 3.49 Bag

Gordon Choice

Marshmallows

Marshmallows, 1 Lb Bag

$3.49
Bag
Price: 3.49 Bag

Gordon Choice

Apple Pie Filling

Filling, Pie, Ready to Use, Apple, #10 Sz Can

$14.99
Can
Price: 14.99 Can

Gordon Choice

Pumpkin

Pumpkin, Fancy, #10, 106 Oz Can

$12.99

Can

$65.99

Case

Chef Pierre

10" Unbaked Pie Shells

Shells, Pie, Unbaked 10 Inch, Plain, Frozen, 5 Ct Package

$9.99
Package
Price: 9.99 Package

Gold Medal

All-Purpose Flour

Flour, All-Purpose, Bleached, Enriched, 5 Lb Package

$6.99

Package

$42.99

Case

Brown Sugar

Sugar, Brown, Light, 2 Lb Bag

$2.99
Bag
Price: 2.99 Bag

Extra Fine Granulated Sugar

Sugar, Beet, Granulated, Extra Fine, 10 Lb Bag

$8.99
Bag
Price: 8.99 Bag

Palmer

Vanilla Almond Bark

Almond Bark, Vanilla, 20 Oz Bag

$5.49
Bag
Price: 5.49 Bag

Palmer

Chocolate Almond Bark

Almond Bark, Chocolate, 20 Oz Bag

$5.49
Bag
Price: 5.49 Bag

McCormick

Cinnamon Sugar

Spice, Cinnamon Sugar, 3.62 Oz Jar

$4.49
Jar
Price: 4.49 Jar

McCormick

Ground Cinnamon

Spice, Cinnamon, Ground, 2.37 Oz Each

$3.59
Each
Price: 3.59 Each

Gordon Choice

Pecan Pieces

Pecans, Pieces, Medium, 2.5 Lb Bag

$25.99
Bag
Price: 25.99 Bag

Nilla Wafers

Vanilla Waffer Cookies

Cookies, Vanilla Flavored Wafers, 11 Oz Box

$6.49
Box
Price: 6.49 Box

GFS

Holly Berry Sprinkles

Sprinkles, Holly Berry, 13 Oz Jar

$5.99
Jar
Price: 5.99 Jar

GFS

White, Red & Green Sprinkles

Sprinkles, Red/Green/White, 13 Oz Jar

$4.99
Jar
Price: 4.99 Jar

GFS

Non-Pareil Jingle Mix

Sprinkles, Nonpareil, Jingle Mix, 16 Oz Jar

$5.99
Jar
Price: 5.99 Jar

Pillsbury

Funfetti Red Frosting

Frosting, Vanilla, Funfetti, Red, 15.6 Oz Each

$2.99
Each
Price: 2.99 Each

Pillsbury

Funfetti Green Frosting

Frosting, Vanilla, Funfetti, Green with Sprinkles, 15.6 Oz Tub

$2.99
Tub
Price: 2.99 Tub

Eagle Brand

Sweet Condensed Milk

Milk, Condensed, Sweetened, Shelf-Stable, 14 Fl Oz Can

$3.79
Can
Price: 3.79 Can

Pioneer Powdered Sugar

Sugar, Powdered, 10X, 2 Lb Bag

$2.99
Bag
Price: 2.99 Bag

Arm & Hammer

Baking Soda

Baking Soda, 16 Oz Package

$1.89
Package
Price: 1.89 Package

McCormick

Pure Vanilla Extract

Extract, Vanilla, Pure, 1 Fl Oz Box

$4.49
Box
Price: 4.49 Box

McCormick

Pure Peppermint Extract

Extract, Peppermint, Pure, 2 Fl Oz Box

$6.99
Box
Price: 6.99 Box

Domino

Brown Sugar

Sugar, Brown, Dark, 1 Lb Package

$2.19
Package
Price: 2.19 Package
Sale
Vegetable Oil | Packaged

Vegetable Oil

Oil, Vegetable, 48 Fl Oz Bottle

$4.99
Bottle
Price: 4.99 Bottle

Gordon Choice

Butter Flavor Cooking Spray

Spray, Pan Coating, Buttery Flavored, Canola Oil, No Trans Fat, 16.5 Oz Can

$5.99
Can
Price: 5.99 Can
Baking Supplies