Our website has detected that you are using Internet Explorer (IE) - a browser we no longer support. We recommend switching browsers to avoid issues with features on the site. View supported browsers here.

Jif
Creamy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Smooth, 40 Oz Jar

$7.49
Jar
Price: 7.49 Jar

Smucker's
Grape Jelly

Jelly, Grape, 48 Oz Jar

$5.99
Jar
Price: 5.99 Jar

Jif
Creamy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Creamy, Retail Plastic, 16 Oz Package

$3.79
Package
Price: 3.79 Package

Gordon Choice
Light Amber Clover Honey

Honey, U.S. Grade A, Light Amber, 6 Lb Jug

$24.99
Jug
Price: 24.99 Jug

Smucker's
Concord Grape Jam

Jelly & Jam, Concorde Grape, 32 Oz Jar

$3.99
Jar
Price: 3.99 Jar

Smucker's
Strawberry Jam

Jelly & Jelly, Strawberry, 32 Oz Jar

$5.99
Jar
Price: 5.99 Jar

Gordon Choice
Grape Jelly

Jelly, Grape, 4 Lb Jar

$9.99
Jar
Price: 9.99 Jar

Brickman's
Honey Bear Squeeze Bottle

Honey, Bear, Squeeze, 12 Oz Package

$3.99
Package
Price: 3.99 Package

Gordon Choice
Clover Honey

Honey, 3 Ct Package

$18.49
Package
Price: 18.49 Package

Gordon Choice
Smooth Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Smooth, 5 Lb Tub

$14.49
Tub
Price: 14.49 Tub

Bonne Maman
Raspberry Preserve

Preserves, Raspberry, 13 Oz Package

$7.99
Package
Price: 7.99 Package

Jif
Crunchy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Crunchy, 40 Oz Jar

$7.49
Jar
Price: 7.49 Jar

Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Spread

Spread, Nut, 35.3 Oz Jar

$10.50
Jar
Price: 10.50 Jar

IO Brand
Organic Honey

Honey, Organic, 16 Oz Each

$8.99
Each
Price: 8.99 Each

Borrelli
Tomato Paste

Paste, Tomato, 6 Oz Each

$1.49
Each
Price: 1.49 Each

Ditka's Giardiniera

Giariniera, Hot, 16 Oz Jar

$6.49
Jar
Price: 6.49 Jar

Inspired Organics
Organic Raspberry Fruit Spread

Fruit Spread, Organic, Raspberry, Seedless, 10 Oz Jar

$4.49
Jar
Price: 4.49 Jar

Jif
Creamy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Creamy, 7g of Protein Per Serving, 28 Oz Jar

$6.49
Jar
Price: 6.49 Jar

Inspired Organics
Organic Strawberry Fruit Spread

Fruit Spread, Organic, Strawberry, 10 Oz Jar

$4.49
Jar
Price: 4.49 Jar

Gordon Choice
Orange Marmalade

Marmalade, Orange, 4 Lb Jar

$12.99
Jar
Price: 12.99 Jar

Gordon Choice
Crunchy Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter, Crunchy, 5 Lb Tub

$15.49
Tub
Price: 15.49 Tub

Divina
Fig Spread

Spread, Fig, 9 Oz Jar

$5.99
Jar
Price: 5.99 Jar

Bonne Maman Preserves

Preserves, Apricot, 13 Oz Each

$7.99
Each
Price: 7.99 Each

Inspired Organics
Organic Blueberry Fruit Spread

Fruit Spread, Organic, Blueberry, 10 Oz Jar

$4.49
Jar
Price: 4.49 Jar